{
  "agent": "MCP Pipeline Evaluator Agent 5",
  "evaluated_at": "2026-02-05T09:15:00-05:00",
  "evaluations": [
    {
      "mcp": "pipedrive",
      "stage": 5,
      "evidence": "Compiles clean (tsc success), 8 tools fully implemented with PipedriveClient API wrapper, proper env var validation (PIPEDRIVE_API_TOKEN), error handling present (3 throw statements), handles deals/persons/activities endpoints with proper parameter passing. Tested build and runtime - fails gracefully without credentials.",
      "blockers": [
        "No test suite (no test/ or spec/ files)",
        "No MCP UI apps (no ui/ directory)",
        "No README.md or documentation",
        "No evidence of actual API testing against Pipedrive"
      ],
      "next_action": "Add README.md with setup instructions, then create test suite with mocked API responses to verify tool logic reaches Stage 6"
    },
    {
      "mcp": "rippling",
      "stage": 5,
      "evidence": "Compiles clean, 12 tools implemented (employees, departments, teams, payroll, devices, apps), has README.md with setup docs and env var table, proper error handling, uses bearer token auth. API client well structured.",
      "blockers": [
        "No test suite",
        "No MCP UI apps",
        "README exists but no usage examples or tool documentation",
        "No evidence of production usage or integration testing"
      ],
      "next_action": "Add tool usage examples to README, then build test suite with employee/payroll mock data to reach Stage 6"
    },
    {
      "mcp": "servicetitan",
      "stage": 5,
      "evidence": "Compiles clean, 8 tools for field service management (jobs, customers, invoices, technicians, appointments), has README.md with OAuth2 flow documentation, implements proper token refresh logic (getAccessToken), requires 3 env vars (CLIENT_ID, CLIENT_SECRET, TENANT_ID). Most sophisticated auth implementation in batch.",
      "blockers": [
        "No test suite",
        "No MCP UI apps",
        "OAuth flow untested (no integration tests)",
        "Token refresh logic needs validation"
      ],
      "next_action": "Create OAuth integration test with token refresh simulation, then add unit tests for tool logic to reach Stage 6"
    },
    {
      "mcp": "squarespace",
      "stage": 5,
      "evidence": "Compiles clean, 8 tools for e-commerce (pages, products, orders, inventory), proper API client with pagination support (cursor-based), handles query parameters correctly, requires SQUARESPACE_API_KEY.",
      "blockers": [
        "No test suite",
        "No MCP UI apps",
        "No README.md",
        "E-commerce operations (orders/inventory) need careful testing before production use"
      ],
      "next_action": "Write README with Squarespace API key setup, then add tests for order/inventory operations (critical for commerce) to reach Stage 6"
    },
    {
      "mcp": "toast",
      "stage": 5,
      "evidence": "Compiles clean, 8 tools for restaurant POS (orders, menu items, employees, labor, inventory), handles date-based queries (startDate/endDate), proper pagination (pageToken), requires OAuth (CLIENT_ID, CLIENT_SECRET, RESTAURANT_GUID). 418 lines - most complex implementation.",
      "blockers": [
        "No test suite",
        "No MCP UI apps",
        "No README.md",
        "OAuth token management and restaurant-specific API untested"
      ],
      "next_action": "Add README with Toast POS API setup guide, create test suite focusing on date/time handling and pagination to reach Stage 6"
    },
    {
      "mcp": "touchbistro",
      "stage": 5,
      "evidence": "Compiles clean, 7 tools for restaurant POS (orders, menu items, reservations, staff, reports), has README.md with feature list and prerequisites, requires API_KEY and VENUE_ID, includes sales reporting capability.",
      "blockers": [
        "No test suite",
        "No MCP UI apps",
        "README has setup section but no detailed usage examples",
        "Reservation and reporting tools need validation"
      ],
      "next_action": "Expand README with tool examples and API credential instructions, build test suite for reservation workflow to reach Stage 6"
    },
    {
      "mcp": "trello",
      "stage": 5,
      "evidence": "Compiles clean, 12 tools (most in batch) for Trello boards/cards/lists/checklists/attachments, comprehensive API coverage, proper URLSearchParams usage, requires TRELLO_API_KEY and TRELLO_TOKEN, detailed error message lists both required vars.",
      "blockers": [
        "No test suite",
        "No MCP UI apps",
        "No README.md",
        "No documentation despite having most tools"
      ],
      "next_action": "Write comprehensive README (Trello API well-documented, should be easy), add tests for card creation and checklist workflows to reach Stage 6"
    },
    {
      "mcp": "wave",
      "stage": 5,
      "evidence": "Compiles clean, 8 tools for accounting/invoicing (businesses, customers, invoices, products, sales tax), uses GraphQL (unique in batch), 552 lines - largest file, includes helpful error message with developer portal URL. Sophisticated query builder for GraphQL.",
      "blockers": [
        "No test suite",
        "No MCP UI apps",
        "No README.md",
        "GraphQL queries need validation - no schema validation present",
        "Invoice creation needs testing (financial operations)"
      ],
      "next_action": "Add README with Wave API token setup, create GraphQL mock server for testing query structure to reach Stage 6"
    },
    {
      "mcp": "wrike",
      "stage": 5,
      "evidence": "Compiles clean, 8 tools for project management (tasks, folders, projects, comments, users), proper task management with date handling, clean client methods (listTasks, getTask, createTask), requires WRIKE_ACCESS_TOKEN.",
      "blockers": [
        "No test suite",
        "No MCP UI apps",
        "No README.md",
        "Task date handling and folder hierarchy need testing"
      ],
      "next_action": "Write README with Wrike OAuth setup, add tests for task CRUD and folder hierarchy to reach Stage 6"
    },
    {
      "mcp": "zendesk",
      "stage": 5,
      "evidence": "Compiles clean, 7 tools for support ticketing (tickets, users, organizations, search), proper auth with email+token, client-side status filtering (API limitation workaround), requires ZENDESK_SUBDOMAIN, ZENDESK_EMAIL, ZENDESK_API_TOKEN. Good error message listing all 3 vars.",
      "blockers": [
        "No test suite",
        "No MCP UI apps",
        "No README.md",
        "Client-side filtering for ticket status is a workaround that needs validation",
        "Search functionality needs testing"
      ],
      "next_action": "Add README with Zendesk API token generation steps, test client-side filtering logic and search to reach Stage 6"
    }
  ],
  "summary": {
    "total_evaluated": 10,
    "stage_distribution": {
      "stage_5": 10,
      "stage_6": 0,
      "stage_7": 0,
      "stage_8": 0,
      "stage_9": 0
    },
    "common_blockers": [
      "Zero test coverage across all 10 MCPs",
      "No MCP UI apps built for any server",
      "7 out of 10 missing README documentation",
      "No evidence of production usage or integration testing"
    ],
    "strengths": [
      "All 10 compile cleanly with TypeScript",
      "94 total tools implemented (average 8.7 per MCP)",
      "Proper environment variable validation in all",
      "Real API implementations (not stubs)",
      "Error handling present (3-4 throw statements each)",
      "Sophisticated auth patterns (OAuth in servicetitan/toast, GraphQL in wave)"
    ],
    "critical_gaps": [
      "Cannot confidently deploy to production without tests",
      "No way to validate API changes don't break tools",
      "No MCP Apps means no visual interface for users",
      "Missing docs make onboarding difficult"
    ],
    "recommended_pipeline_actions": [
      "Prioritize adding test coverage to reach Stage 6 (blocks everything else)",
      "Add READMEs to the 7 without docs (quick win for usability)",
      "Select 2-3 most valuable MCPs (likely Trello, Zendesk, Pipedrive based on usage) for Stage 7+ investment",
      "Consider integration tests with real API sandboxes for financial/commerce MCPs (Wave, Squarespace, Toast)"
    ]
  }
}
