beeble-forensic-analysis/evidence/marketing_claims.md
Nicholai 86accadc28 docs: add competitive landscape and deep dive findings
Version evolution (SL 1.0→2.0→3.0), team background, no
patents, NVIDIA DiffusionRenderer as open-source competitor,
dataset landscape (POLAR, SynthLight, etc.), botocore/AWS SDK
in privacy app, MetaHuman EULA fix, user data controversy,
and DiffusionRenderer ComfyUI integration across all docs.
2026-01-26 12:41:01 -07:00

340 lines
13 KiB
Markdown

# Beeble Marketing Claims Archive
Exact quotes from Beeble's public-facing pages, archived January 2026.
These are provided for reference so readers can compare marketing
language against the technical findings documented in this repository.
All quotes are reproduced verbatim. Emphasis (bold) is preserved as
it appears on the original pages.
## beeble.ai/beeble-studio
Page title: "Production-Grade 4K AI Relighting, Fully On-Device"
Main heading: "4K Relighting Fully on Your Machine"
Subheading: "DESKTOP APP FOR LOCAL PROCESSING"
Feature description (Local AI Model section):
> Run our most advanced **Video-to-PBR model, SwitchLight 3**, directly
> on your desktop. Perfect for professionals who need local workflow.
Video-to-Assets feature card:
> **PBR, Alpha & Depth Map Generation**
> Powered by **SwitchLight 3.0**, convert images and videos into
> **full PBR passes with alpha and depth maps** for seamless
> relighting, background removal, and advanced compositing.
FAQ on the same page ("What is Beeble Studio?"):
> **Beeble Studio** is our desktop application that runs entirely on
> your local hardware. It provides:
> - Local GPU Processing: Process up to 4K and 1 hour using your
> NVIDIA GPU
> - Unlimited Rendering: No credit consumption for Video-to-VFX
> - Complete Privacy: Your files never leave your machine
>
> Same AI Models: Access to SwitchLight 3.0 and all core features
Source: https://beeble.ai/beeble-studio
## beeble.ai/research/switchlight-3-0-is-here
Published: November 5, 2025
Headline: "Introducing the best Video-to-PBR model in the world"
Opening paragraph:
> SwitchLight 3.0 is the best Video-to-PBR model in the world. It
> delivers unmatched quality in generating physically based rendering
> (PBR) passes from any video, setting a new standard for VFX
> professionals and filmmakers who demand true production-level
> relighting.
On the "true video model" claim:
> **True Video Model:** For the first time, SwitchLight is a **true
> video model** that processes multiple frames simultaneously. Earlier
> versions relied on single-frame image processing followed by a
> separate deflicker step. In version 3.0, temporal consistency is
> built directly into the model, delivering smoother, more stable
> results while preserving sharp detail.
On training data:
> **10x Larger Training Set:** Trained on a dataset ten times bigger,
> SwitchLight 3.0 captures a broader range of lighting conditions,
> materials, and environments for more realistic results.
Detail quality claim:
> SwitchLight 3.0 achieves a new level of detail and visual clarity.
> Compared to 2.0, it captures **finer facial definition, intricate
> fabric wrinkles, and sophisticated surface patterns** with far
> greater accuracy.
Motion handling:
> SwitchLight 3.0 is a **true end-to-end video model** that
> understands motion natively. Unlike SwitchLight 2.0, which relied
> on an image model and post-smoothing, it eliminates **flicker and
> ghosting** even in extreme motion, shaking cameras, or vibrating
> subjects.
Source: https://beeble.ai/research/switchlight-3-0-is-here
## docs.beeble.ai/help/faq
"Is Beeble's AI trained responsibly?":
> **Yes.** Beeble's proprietary models--such as **SwitchLight**--are
> trained only on ethically sourced, agreement-based datasets. We
> never use scraped or unauthorized data.
>
> When open-source models are included, we choose them
> carefully--only those with published research papers that disclose
> their training data and carry valid commercial-use licenses.
"What is Video-to-VFX?":
> **Video-to-VFX** uses our foundation model, **SwitchLight 3.0**,
> and SOTA AI models to convert your footage into VFX-ready assets
> by generating:
> - **PBR Maps:** Normal, Base color, Metallic, Roughness, Specular
> for relighting
> - **Alpha:** foreground matte for background replacement
> - **Depth Map:** For compositing and 3D integration
Source: https://docs.beeble.ai/help/faq
## docs.beeble.ai/beeble-studio/video-to-vfx
Product documentation page:
> **Video-to-VFX** uses our foundation model, SwitchLight 3.0, to
> convert your footage into VFX-ready assets.
Key Features section:
> **PBR, Alpha & Depth Pass Generation**
> Powered by **SwitchLight 3.0**. Convert footage into full PBR
> passes with alpha and depth maps.
Source: https://docs.beeble.ai/beeble-studio/video-to-vfx
## Investor and press coverage
### Seed funding (July 2024)
Beeble raised a $4.75M seed round at a reported $25M valuation. The
round was led by Basis Set Ventures and Fika Ventures. At the time
of funding, the company had approximately 7 employees.
Press coverage from the funding round:
> Beeble [...] has raised $4.75 million in seed funding to develop
> its **foundational model** for AI-powered relighting in video.
Source: TechCrunch and other outlets, July 2024
Investor quotes (public press releases):
Basis Set Ventures described SwitchLight as a "world-class
foundational model in lighting" in their investment rationale.
The term "foundational model" is significant. In the AI industry,
it implies a large-scale, general-purpose model trained from scratch
on diverse data--models like GPT-4, DALL-E, or Stable Diffusion.
The technical evidence suggests Beeble's pipeline is a collection of
open-source models (some used directly, others used as architectural
building blocks) with proprietary weights trained on domain-specific
data. Whether this constitutes a "foundational model" is a
characterization question, but it is a characterization that was
used to secure investment.
As of January 2026, the company appears to have approximately 9
employees.
## Version history
| Version | Approximate date | Key changes |
|---------|-----------------|-------------|
| SwitchLight (mobile app) | 2022-2023 | Photo relighting app for iOS, 3M+ downloads claimed. Selfie/portrait focus. |
| SwitchLight 1.0 | Late 2023 - early 2024 | First VFX tool. Required alpha mask input. Isolated humans only. Architecture described in CVPR 2024 paper. Per-frame processing. |
| SwitchLight 2.0 | June 30, 2025 | "Complete architecture rebuild." No alpha mask required. Full-scene PBR maps (not just isolated subjects). Claimed 10x larger model, 13x more training data than 1.0. Still per-frame with post-processing deflicker. 2K resolution limit (cloud). 8-bit PNG output. User data training controversy (see below). |
| SwitchLight 3.0 | November 5, 2025 | Marketed as "true video model" with multi-frame processing. Claimed 10x more training data than 2.0 (130x more than 1.0). 4K resolution support. 16-bit EXR output. Desktop app (Beeble Studio) launched for local GPU processing. Paid users exempt from data training. |
Source: beeble.ai/research/switchlight-2-0-is-here,
beeble.ai/research/switchlight-3-0-is-here
## Team and leadership
Beeble was founded in 2022 in Seoul, South Korea by five co-founders
who previously worked at the AI research and machine learning team of
Krafton Inc., a South Korean game publisher.
**CEO: Hoon Kim**
- B.S. and M.S. in Electrical Engineering from KAIST (2012-2019)
- Research scientist at Lunit (medical AI, 2019-2020)
- Deep learning research scientist at Krafton Inc. (voice synthesis
team leader, 2020-2022)
- 6 peer-reviewed papers at ICLR, AAAI, ICML workshop
- Prior research was in autonomous driving (sim-to-real transfer,
vehicle collision prediction) and voice synthesis--not in computer
vision, relighting, or PBR decomposition
- The SwitchLight paper is his first publication in relighting
Source: gnsrla12.github.io/About-myself/
**Paper co-author: Sanghyun Woo** (last/senior author on the CVPR paper)
- Ph.D. from KAIST, currently Senior Research Scientist at Google
DeepMind
- Previously Faculty Fellow at NYU Courant (hosted by Saining Xie)
- Creator of CBAM (Convolutional Block Attention Module, ECCV 2018)
with 34,000+ citations
- Co-author on ConvNeXt V2 (CVPR 2023), Cambrian-1 (NeurIPS 2024 Oral)
- Listed as affiliated with NYU on the SwitchLight paper, not Beeble
- Whether his involvement extends beyond the CVPR 2024 paper is
unknown
Source: sites.google.com/view/sanghyunwoo/
**Team size:** 9 employees as of early 2026. With 5 co-founders, this
means approximately 4 non-founder employees.
## Products and pricing
**Beeble Cloud** (web app): Credit-based processing. Free tier
(15-second clips), Creator $19/month, Professional $75/month.
**Beeble Studio** (desktop app): Local GPU processing.
Indie $504/year ($42/month, for studios under $200K revenue),
Standard $3,000/year ($250/month).
**SwitchLight API**: Available at switchlight-api.beeble.ai for
developer integration.
**Mobile app**: SwitchLight photo editor on iOS, 3M+ downloads
claimed. This is a consumer selfie relighting app, not a professional
VFX tool.
**Plugins**: Nuke, Blender, Unreal Engine integration.
The original SwitchLight Studio product was shut down and merged into
Beeble Studio. The switchlight-studio.beeble.ai domain displays a
"Closing" notice.
Source: beeble.ai/pricing, beeble.ai/pricing-cloud
## User data training controversy
When SwitchLight 2.0 launched in mid-2025, CG Channel reported that
Beeble's terms of use allowed user-uploaded content to be used for AI
training. This caused significant backlash in the VFX community, where
studios are protective of proprietary footage.
Beeble responded by changing policy: paid subscribers' content is no
longer used for training (as of the SwitchLight 3.0 launch in November
2025). Free tier uploads may still be used. The Beeble Studio desktop
app was positioned as the privacy-focused alternative, with all
processing running locally.
Source: cgchannel.com/2025/11/beeble-launches-switchlight-3-0/
## Interview statements
In a September 2025 interview with Digital Production magazine
("We have to talk about Switchlight 2.0"), CEO Hoon Kim stated:
> At its core, it's a neural net doing the heavy lifting.
When asked for architecture details, he said he "couldn't share more
details beyond that."
On training data, Kim stated all data was "created in-house using
scans of real humans and objects" with "no movies, films, or
third-party content used."
Source: digitalproduction.com/2025/09/05/we-have-to-talk-about-switchlight-2-0/
## Production credits
Boxel Studio used SwitchLight for VFX relighting sequences on
*Superman & Lois*. This appears to be Beeble's most prominent
production credit.
Source: boxelstudio.com/beeble-switchlight/
## Patent filings
No patent applications or grants were found for Beeble Inc. or any of
its founders related to SwitchLight, relighting, or inverse rendering.
Searches were conducted on USPTO Patent Public Search and Google
Patents for "Beeble," "Hoon Kim," "SwitchLight," and "portrait
relighting neural network."
Note: Patent applications have an 18-month publication delay from
filing, so recent applications may not yet be visible.
Searched: January 2026
## CVPR paper reception
The SwitchLight paper was accepted as a CVPR 2024 highlight paper
(top ~10% of accepted papers out of 11,532 submissions). Beeble
claimed perfect 5/5/5 reviewer scores.
The paper is cited as "state-of-the-art" in IC-Light's ICLR 2025
paper and is referenced in the Awesome-Relighting curated list.
No public criticisms of the paper were found, though CVPR reviews
are confidential.
The paper has no associated code release. The beeble-ai/SwitchLight-
Studio GitHub repository contains only desktop application scripts
and integration helpers, not model code. For a CVPR highlight paper,
the absence of a code release is notable.
The arXiv version is licensed CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 (non-commercial).
Source: x.com/beeble_ai/status/1763564054529159548
## Community presence
As of January 2026, there is minimal Reddit discussion of Beeble or
SwitchLight on r/vfx, r/compositing, or r/NukeVFX. For a tool that
has been used on a major television production (Superman & Lois) and
claims 3M mobile app downloads, the lack of organic community
discussion is notable.
There is a separate, unrelated company called "Beeble" (based in
Latvia, offering encrypted email and cloud storage) that has an
AppSumo listing with poor reviews. This is not the same as Beeble AI
but creates brand confusion.
## Notable patterns
Beeble's marketing consistently attributes the entire Video-to-VFX
pipeline to SwitchLight 3.0. The Beeble Studio page states that PBR,
alpha, and depth map generation are all "Powered by SwitchLight 3.0."
The FAQ is the only place where Beeble acknowledges the use of
open-source models, stating they "choose them carefully" and select
those with "valid commercial-use licenses." However, the FAQ does not
name any of the specific open-source models used, nor does it clarify
which pipeline stages use open-source components versus SwitchLight.
The overall marketing impression is that SwitchLight is responsible
for all output passes. The technical reality, as documented in this
repository's analysis, is that background removal (alpha) and depth
estimation are produced by open-source models used off the shelf,
and the PBR decomposition models appear to be architecturally built
from open-source frameworks (segmentation_models_pytorch, timm
backbones) with proprietary trained weights. See
[docs/REPORT.md](../docs/REPORT.md) for the full analysis.